Direct Seeding vs Table Seeding: What's Best for Your Tower Garden?

One of the most common questions we hear from growers is:
Should I seed directly in my Tower, or start seeds on a table first? 🤔

The good news? Both methods work beautifully. The best choice really depends on what you’re growing, your environment, and how hands-on you want to be. Let’s break it down 👇

  1. Option 1: Direct Seeding in the Tower
  2. Option 2: Seeding Rockwool on a Table
  3. Side-by-side Comparison
  4. So Which Method Should You Use?
  5. Want Better Seedling Results?
  6. Final Thoughts

🌿 Option 1: Direct Seeding in the Tower

Direct seeding means placing seeds straight into rockwool cubes that are already loaded into your Tower Garden ports.

✅ Pros of Direct Seeding

  • No watering guesswork – seedlings are automatically watered by the Tower, so you don’t have to worry about drying out or overwatering 💧🙌
  • Less handling overall – seed it once and let the Tower do its thing
  • Roots grow undisturbed from day one
  • Simpler setup – fewer trays, domes, and steps to manage
  • Great for fast, forgiving crops like lettuce, arugula, mustard greens, and herbs
  • Ideal for cool-germinating seeds – crops that prefer cooler temps (👀 looking at you, spinach) often germinate well in the Tower’s cooler water ❄️🌱

❌ Cons of Direct Seeding

  • Slower early growth is common – cooler Tower water can slow germination and early development compared to table-started seedlings
  • Less direct sun at first – the rockwool sits slightly below the edge of the growing pot, which can shade tiny seedlings and cause a slower start until they grow above the pot
  • Slows crop turnover – because seeds are germinating in the Tower, it takes longer to get from planting to harvest
  • Not ideal for heat-loving crops without supplemental warmth early on 🌡️🌱

👉 Best for:
Leafy greens, cool-season crops, and growers who value simplicity over speed 😄🌿

🌱 Option 2: Seeding Rockwool on a Table

Table seeding means starting seeds in rockwool cubes placed in trays or flats—then moving the seedlings into the Tower once they’re established.

✅ Pros of Table Seeding

  • Warmer conditions = faster germination 🌡️
  • Stronger early growth thanks to full light exposure right from the start
  • Easy to spot duds or weak seedlings before they hit the Tower
  • More uniform, full Towers with fewer empty ports
  • Ideal for slower or warm-loving crops like tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, and flowers

❌ Cons of Table Seeding

  • Extra step required (transplanting)
  • Small risk of transplant stress if cubes dry out or roots are damaged
  • Watering requires attention—rockwool can dry out or stay too wet

👉 Best for:
Growers who want faster starts, stronger seedlings, and tighter harvest timing 🌱✨

⚖️ Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature Direct Seeding Table Seeding
Setup Simplicity ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐
Watering Effort ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (automatic) ⭐⭐
Early Growth Speed ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Germination Control ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Light Exposure Early On ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Crop Turnover Speed ⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Cool-Season Crop Success ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐

🌞 So… Which Method Should You Use?

✨ Choose direct seeding if:

  • You’re growing cool-season crops like spinach
  • You want the Tower to handle watering for you
  • You’re okay with a slower, more relaxed harvest rhythm

✨ Choose table seeding if:

  • You want fast, consistent harvest cycles
  • You’re growing warm-season crops in cooler seasons
  • You like having seedlings ready to go when a port opens up

💡 Real-world grower tip:
Many experienced growers use both methods at the same time—direct seeding when conditions are right, and table seeding to keep harvests rolling without gaps. 🙌🌿

🌿 Want Better Seedling Results?

If you’re troubleshooting germination issues or want to dial in your seed-starting game even more, these two guides will help 👇

🌱 How to Grow the Perfect Seedling
Learn the ideal moisture, temperature, light, and timing to grow strong, healthy seedlings from day one.

🌱 Why Didn’t My Seeds Germinate?
A deep dive into the most common reasons seeds fail—and how to fix them before your next planting.

🌿 Final Thoughts

Direct seeding shines for simplicity and cool-season crops, while table seeding often wins for speed, consistency, and efficient crop cycling. Neither method is wrong—it’s all about matching the crop to the conditions and your growing goals 💚

If you want predictable harvests, table seeding usually takes the win.
If you want fewer steps and less babysitting, direct seeding still has its place 😄🌱

Back to blog

🌿 Frequently Asked Questions: Direct Seeding vs. Table Seeding

  • Can I seed directly in my Tower Garden?

    Yes! You can seed directly in rockwool that’s already in your Tower Garden. This works especially well for leafy greens and cool-season crops, though early growth may be slower than table-started seedlings.

  • Why do seedlings sometimes grow slower when direct seeded in the Tower?

    When seeds are started directly in the Tower, cooler water temperatures and slightly reduced light exposure early on can slow initial growth. Once seedlings grow above the pot, growth usually picks up.

  • Is table seeding better for beginners?

    Table seeding is often easier for beginners because it allows more control over temperature, moisture, and light during germination. It also makes it easier to ensure every Tower port is filled.

  • Which crops should I direct seed in the Tower?

    Fast-growing, cool-season crops like lettuce, arugula, kale, and spinach tend to do well when direct seeded, especially during cooler months.

  • Which crops are better started on a table?

    Warm-season and slower-growing crops such as tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, cucumbers, and flowers usually perform better when started on a table and transplanted into the Tower.

  • Does direct seeding reduce transplant shock?

    Yes. Since plants stay in one place from germination through harvest, direct seeding eliminates transplant shock entirely.

  • Why does table seeding help with crop cycling?

    Because seedlings are already established when transplanted, table seeding shortens the time between planting and harvest, making it easier to maintain consistent production and steady harvests.

  • Can I use both methods at the same time?

    Absolutely. Many experienced growers direct seed cool-season greens while table seeding warm-season crops to keep their Tower producing year-round.

  • What’s the most common mistake with table seeding?

    Overwatering or underwatering rockwool cubes. Rockwool should stay moist but not saturated. Poor moisture control is a common cause of failed germination.

  • What should I do if my seeds don’t germinate?

    Check seed temperature requirements, moisture levels, seed depth, and seed quality. If you’re still struggling, our guides How to Grow the Perfect Seedling and Why Didn’t My Seeds Germinate? go deeper into troubleshooting.